Gusto is best-in-class — for US payroll. Peoplifi handles Pakistan, Gulf, and multi-currency teams Gusto cannot serve.
If your entire team is US-based, stay with Gusto. The moment you have employees outside the US, Peoplifi handles what Gusto cannot — at similar or lower cost.
Gusto is the dominant US small-business payroll provider, with excellent UX, benefits marketplace, and 1099 contractor support. It is a US-only product: no Pakistan, no Gulf, no multi-currency.
Simple: $40/mo base + $6 per employee. Plus: $80/mo base + $12/employee. Premium: $180/mo base + $22/employee. US only.
$3 per seat per month (Starter, includes global payroll). PKR 840 in Pakistan. No per-month base fee.
US-only SMBs under 100 employees with full-time US staff and US benefits.
Pakistan-based SMBs, international tech companies, agencies hiring globally, and any team with non-US payroll needs.
For small US teams, yes. For teams with complex US benefits or multi-state filings, most customers keep Gusto for US employees and use Peoplifi for everyone else via our Gusto integration.
Peoplifi generates W-2 and 1099-ready data but relies on partner integrations for actual IRS filing. Gusto filings remain the gold standard for US-only compliance.
Yes. Peoplifi generates Rule 44 monthly statements and Section 149 annual statements in IRIS-ready format. We are used by 500+ Pakistan businesses.
Gusto is one of the most-loved US payroll platforms with deep US-tax compliance, automated W-2 / 1099-NEC generation, integrated benefits administration, and excellent customer support. For US-only operations, Gusto is genuinely best-in-class. For Pakistani operations, Gusto has structural limitations: no native FBR Section 149 average-rate tax engine, no EOBI compliance, no multi-province social security handling, no IBFT bank file generation, no Form 149 / Rule 44 / Section 165 reporting. Gusto's international support is limited to international contractors via Gusto Embedded; full multi-country payroll for international W-2-equivalent employees is not in product scope.
For organisations with both US W-2 employees and Pakistani staff, the cleanest stack is often Gusto for US plus Peoplifi for Pakistan. Gusto handles (1) US W-2 employee payroll with deep tax compliance. (2) US benefits administration. (3) US-specific compliance (FLSA, ACA, state-paid-sick-leave). (4) IRS filings. Peoplifi handles (1) Pakistani direct-hire employees with full FBR Section 149 / EOBI / provincial social security compliance. (2) IBFT bank-file generation for Pakistani corporate banking. (3) Bilingual English/Urdu payslips. (4) Pakistan-specific compliance reporting. The two integrate via API for HR-record sync, providing a clean operational model that uses each platform for its strengths.
Some US-headquartered companies hiring Pakistani staff initially try to extend Gusto to handle Pakistani payroll. This typically fails because (1) **No Section 149 engine** — Pakistani income-tax withholding requires manual workarounds. (2) **No EOBI compliance** — Pakistani employees aren't enrolled in EOBI through Gusto, creating compliance gaps. (3) **No IBFT generation** — Pakistani salary disbursement requires a separate manual file preparation process. (4) **No bilingual payslips** — Pakistani employees receive US-format payslips. (5) **No Pakistani statutory leave handling** — annual leave under Factories Act 1934, casual leave under Standing Orders Ordinance, maternity under Maternity Benefit Ordinance 1958 require manual policy implementation. The compliance gaps grow with Pakistani headcount and eventually require a Pakistani-native platform regardless.
For US-only organisations, Gusto's pricing (USD 40 base + USD 6/employee for Simple, USD 80 + 12 for Plus) is competitive. For Pakistani-only organisations, Gusto's USD-denominated pricing converted to PKR is typically 3-5× higher than Pakistani-native platforms once required US-irrelevant features are stripped out. Peoplifi's PKR-native pricing for Pakistani teams is straightforward and undercuts Gusto for Pakistani configurations. For organisations running both regions, the hybrid Gusto + Peoplifi cost is typically less than running Gusto for both regions while delivering materially better Pakistan compliance.
Common migration scenarios include (1) **Gusto-only to hybrid Gusto + Peoplifi** — keep Gusto for US, add Peoplifi for Pakistan. The lowest-friction path; most operationally clean. (2) **Gusto-managed Pakistan to Peoplifi** — move Pakistani staff off Gusto's manual workarounds onto proper Pakistani compliance. Standard 1-2 week migration. (3) **Pakistani-only platform to hybrid** — for Pakistani companies expanding to US, add Gusto for US W-2 employees while continuing Peoplifi for Pakistani operations. Each path has standard procedures and integration-via-API for ongoing data consistency.
Start your free 7-day trial — no credit card required.
Start free 7-day trial